Show Dates and Times:

November 3rd - 7:30 PM

November 4th - 7:30 PM

November 5th - 2:00 PM

November 10th - 7:30 PM

November 11th  - 7:30 PM

November 12th - 2:00 PM

Tickets are non-refundable. In the event you cannot make the show you may use them for another show for up to one year depending on show availability. Email within 10 days after the show date to establish a future credit.

Cast List

Jeter  ....  Kate Rado
Rita  ....  Kat Gonzalez
Old Man  .... Chris Gillespie
Taylor   ....  Ben Kistinger
Mrs. Boyle   ....  Stacey Cohen
Dr. Boyle   ....  Paul Stein
Aunt Dorothy / Officiant   ....  Laurel Lettieri
Leah / Lounge Singer   ....  CJ Umbrino
Angie  ....  Carolyn McCarthy
Waiter    ....  Kaleigh Hilal​

Written by Craig Lucas

Directed by Judy Brewster

Scroll down for ticket purchases

Brewster Theater Company is Sponsored By

This enchanting and thought-provoking play explores the power of love, identity, and the unexpected twists that life can bring. This groundbreaking production puts a new spin on this beautiful story.

The Theater at Drew Methodist

28 Gleneida Avenue - Carmel, NY 10512